What is the difference between custodial and non-custodial wallets?
In a custodial wallet, a third party holds the keys and signs on your behalf. You get an account and an API; the provider carries the licence and the security risk. In a non-custodial wallet, the keys are under your control or your users' control, and no third party can move the funds alone. For a fintech the real question is not the label but who can sign, who can stop a signature, and who answers to the regulator if funds are lost.
How do MPC, multisig, HSMs and secure enclaves protect keys?
- MPC (multi-party computation). The key is split into shares held by different parties or devices. A threshold of them computes a signature together, and the full key is never assembled. The result is an ordinary signature, so it works on most chains.
- Multisig. Several separate keys, and the chain itself enforces that, for example, 2 of 3 must approve. Implemented natively on Bitcoin and TRON, as smart accounts such as Safe on EVM chains, and as programs on Solana.
- HSM or cloud KMS. A certified hardware module generates and keeps the key and signs inside the module. Strong protection, but the full key exists in one place and the module must support the chain's signature curve.
- Secure enclave (TEE). The key lives and signs inside an isolated, attested enclave. Turnkey, for example, keeps keys inside secure enclaves rather than using MPC. Privy splits keys into two shares with Shamir's Secret Sharing and only reassembles them inside AWS Nitro Enclaves to sign.
MPC vs multisig: which should a fintech use?
| Question | MPC | Multisig |
|---|---|---|
| Does it work on every chain you pay out on? | Usually yes | Only where the chain or a smart account supports it |
| Can an auditor see the signing rule on-chain? | No, it lives in the provider or your servers | Yes |
| Does it cost more per transaction? | No | Often yes on EVM chains |
| How hard is key rotation? | Reshare without changing the address | Change owners on-chain |
| What is the lock-in risk? | High: protocol and provider-specific; check key export | Low: open standards |
For high-volume payouts across several chains, MPC or enclave-based wallets are usually the practical choice. For treasury wallets holding large balances on EVM chains, multisig gives a rule that anyone can verify. Many teams use both: MPC hot wallets for payouts, multisig for the treasury that refills them.
Not every "MPC wallet" uses MPC
Providers sell under the same name but protect keys differently. Before you sign, ask each one:
- Is the full private key ever assembled, and where?
- Who holds each share or key, and can the provider sign without you?
- What happens to signing if the provider is down or goes out of business?
- Can you export the key or the shares, and in what format?
- Where are signing policies enforced, and who can change them?
What does regulation expect?
In the EU, holding and controlling crypto-assets for clients is a custody service under MiCA and needs authorisation as a crypto-asset service provider. Using a licensed custodian or payout provider keeps that service with them. EU financial entities also have to treat a wallet provider as an ICT third party under DORA. This is a summary, not legal advice; check your case with counsel.
How to choose for your case
| Your situation | Usual choice |
|---|---|
| Payment platform without a crypto licence, adding payouts | Custodial payout provider (BVNK, Bridge, Circle) |
| Licensed EMI or CASP with volume on several chains | MPC or enclave wallet infrastructure with signing policies (Fireblocks, Turnkey, Dfns, Fordefi) |
| Consumer or business app giving each user a wallet | Embedded wallets (Privy, Turnkey) |
| Treasury with large balances | Multisig or MPC with cold storage and an HSM-held recovery key |
| Strict data-residency or no third-party signing | Self-hosted MPC or HSM |
What do we run?
Since 2018 we have built and operated a permissioned blockchain network (Quorum on AWS) for a bank in the Middle East. It has issued and verified more than 3 million documents, and it runs inside the bank's security framework: ISO 27001, ISO 27017, PCI DSS and NIST SP 800-53.
FAQ
Q01Is MPC safer than multisig?
Neither is safer in general. MPC removes the single full key and works across chains; multisig makes the signing rule public and verifiable. The weakest point is usually the policy around signing, not the cryptography.
Q02Is a non-custodial wallet always better?
No. It moves the security and regulatory responsibility to you. For a fintech without a crypto licence, a custodial provider is often the right first step.
Q03Can we move from a custodial provider to our own MPC later?
Yes, but plan for new addresses, a period of running both, and updates to every counterparty's whitelist.
Q04What is a key ceremony?
The documented, witnessed procedure for creating or recovering keys or key shares.
Disclosure: Vareger integrates the custody and wallet providers named here. We receive no fees from any of them; if that changes, we say so on this page.
